Skip to main content

Find the Best Home and Car Insurance Agents in Norman,Oklahoma

Our top 10 list features verified, licensed insurance agent professionals. Rankings are based on human research, insurance verification, and public record audits.

Top 10 Insurance Agents in Norman

Verified professionals ranked by our comprehensive research methodology

Business logo for Rightway Insurance
Sponsored
Locally Owned
Verified

Rightway Insurance

  • Auto insuranceHomeowners insuranceLife insuranceHealth insuranceBusiness owners policy
  • Commercial auto insuranceFlood insuranceMotorcycle insuranceContractors insurance
  • Farm and ranch insurance

Rightway Insurance is an independent insurance agency representing many different companies for personal and commercial insurance needs. As independent agents, clients can choose the best carrier. The agency educates and services Oklahoma City area communities and throughout Oklahoma with one-on-one service, assessments of insurance needs, and packages that fit best. Offerings include auto, homeowners, boat and watercraft, motorcycle, condo, flood, earthquake, manufactured/mobile home, annuities, disability, business owners policy, farm and ranch, bonds, commercial auto, church, commercial property, contractors, general liability, group health, group life, oil and gas, and more.

Pros

  • Independent agency access to multiple carriers for competitive personalized quotes on auto, home, and business policies

Cons

  • Standard weekday business hours only with no weekend availability
Business logo for Garner Insurance
Sponsored
Locally Owned
Independent
Verified

Garner Insurance

Garner Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving Norman and the greater Oklahoma area. As a veteran-owned business, they bring integrity, discipline, and a commitment to their community in everything they do. Because they work with multiple carriers, they shop rates on your behalf, giving you more options and better value than a single-carrier agent ever could. Whether you need personal coverage like auto, home, flood, or boat insurance, or business protection like general liability, builders risk, or church insurance, Garner Insurance has the experience and local knowledge to find the right fit. Their team is built on relationships, not transactions.

Pros

  • Independent agency providing access to multiple insurance carriers

Cons

  • Closed on weekends
Review Scores
Facebook5.0
Google4.5
Business logo for James Parker - State Farm
Verified

James Parker - State Farm

State Farm® Insurance Agent offering auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, pet insurance, banking, investment services, annuities. Assists with coverage for car, truck, SUV; homeowners & renters; life; health.

Pros

  • Active community involvement, such as supporting youth athletics and local events.

Cons

  • State Farm recently publicized about DEI policies
Business logo for Oklahoma Insurance Group
Verified

Oklahoma Insurance Group

Oklahoma Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency based in Norman, Oklahoma, that shops and compares insurance options to find the best combination of cost and coverage for personal and commercial needs.

Pros

  • Independent agency comparing options from multiple carriers

Cons

  • No published hours which can be confusing for clients
Business logo for Jim Holmes Insurance
Independent
Verified

Jim Holmes Insurance

Independent insurance agency providing affordable insurance quotes and coverage to individuals and businesses in the area, shopping multiple carriers for the best policy options, offering practical solutions, excellent service, and assistance in navigating policy choices.

Pros

  • Family-owned since 1956, providing long-standing experience and personalized service.

Cons

  • Limited media presence
Business logo for Ed Preble Insurance, LLC
Independent
Verified

Ed Preble Insurance, LLC

Independent insurance agency offering personal, commercial, home, auto, farm, and life insurance since 1956.

Pros

  • Family-owned with over 65 years of experience in the industry.

Cons

  • No attachment to national brands
Business logo for Cindy Nashert - State Farm
State Farm
Verified

Cindy Nashert - State Farm

State Farm Insurance Agent offering auto, home, life, health, pet, business insurance, with focus on commercial in Norman. Cindy Nashert has represented State Farm in Norman for a long time and has a great reputation in the community.

Pros

  • Experienced agent since 2000, affiliated since 1989.

Cons

  • Smaller office and representative staff
Business logo for Brian McPherson - Shelter Insurance
Shelter
Verified

Brian McPherson - Shelter Insurance

  • Auto insuranceHomeowners insuranceLife insuranceBusiness insuranceFarmowners insurance
  • Liability insuranceRenters insuranceMotorcycle insuranceBoat and RV insuranceUmbrella insurance

Brian McPherson runs a Shelter Insurance office at 303 East Tonhawa Street in Norman, helping local families and small businesses protect homes, vehicles, lives, and livelihoods through Shelter’s auto, homeowners, life, business, farmowners, and liability products. A University of Oklahoma graduate with a bachelor’s degree in health and sports sciences, McPherson holds the FSCP designation and has more than a dozen years in the industry spanning claims, agency consulting, financial services, and sales. He lives in Norman and works alongside affiliate agent Regan Powell and agency representative Britney Krueger, offering call-or-text access and annual policy reviews so coverage can keep pace as households and businesses change. Licensed in Oklahoma as well as Arkansas, Colorado, Kansas, and Missouri, the office is built for clients who want a named local Shelter agent rather than a distant call center. McPherson’s stated aim is straightforward: the right coverage at the right price, with service that continues after the policy is signed.

Pros

  • Experienced agent with over 12 years in the insurance industry, including claims, consulting, and sales

Cons

  • Smaller office may be noticeable compared to larger agencies
Business logo for Greg Ellis - State Farm
State Farm
Verified

Greg Ellis - State Farm

State Farm Insurance Agent offering auto, home, life, health, pet insurance, banking, and investment services in Norman. Greg Ellis has been a State Farm representative in Norman for over 12 years.

Pros

  • 35 years of State Farm experience.

Cons

  • Some customers report issues with claims processing.
Business logo for J Charles Insurance
Independent
Verified

J Charles Insurance

  • Auto insuranceHomeowners insuranceBusiness insuranceWorkers compensation
  • General liability insuranceGroup health insuranceLife insuranceMedicare coverage
  • Landlord insuranceBoat and motorcycle insurance

J Charles Insurance is an independent agency in northwest Norman founded in 2014 by lifelong resident Justin Charles Peavler, who spent a decade as a sales producer before opening his own shop. From an office at 2276 36th Avenue NW, the firm shops dozens of carriers for personal auto and homeowners coverage, commercial packages, workers compensation, group benefits, life, and Medicare rather than locking clients to a single company. Licensed in Oklahoma and seventeen other states, the agency positions itself as a holistic advisor that customizes policies as households and businesses change. Peavler, a father of three who still coaches youth baseball on weekends, built the practice around a plain promise: more coverage, more savings, and a process that does not feel like a chore. For Norman families and local employers who want an independent shop with a wide market and a named owner in town, J Charles Insurance is set up to compare options, explain the terms, and stay on the account after the policy is bound.

Pros

  • Independent agency with wide variety of insurance solutions

Cons

  • Not part of a unified brand if customers want that